A Think Again Media Group publication
Crime Stumper

Does the FBI really refuse to work with local police?

FBI cooperation: task forces at home and offices abroad

By Phil Springer, Editor · Published · Crime Stumper

FBI cooperation: task forces at home and offices abroad

In July 2008, as the Bureau marked its centennial, the FBI listed the top ten misconceptions about itself. Number three concerned FBI cooperation: the claim that the FBI does not cooperate with other agencies. The Bureau said the news media and the entertainment industry suggest that it routinely stiffs its partners and hogs the credit in big cases. It answered that anyone who worked there would see close relationships, and even friendships, with partners across the country and around the globe. It admitted an occasional conflict, saying the agents are human, and said relationships have been exceptional over the years and improved even more after September 11.

That is a self-portrait of FBI cooperation, so the more useful test is the structure the Bureau describes. It starts with joint task forces at home and liaison offices abroad.

The clearest domestic example of FBI cooperation is the Joint Terrorism Task Force. The FBI calls these units the nation's front line of defense against terrorism and describes them as groups of investigators, analysts, linguists and other specialists drawn from dozens of U.S. law enforcement and intelligence agencies. The first one was set up in New York City in 1980. Today there are about 200 task forces, with at least one in each of the FBI's 55 field offices and hundreds of participating state, local and federal agencies. A National Joint Terrorism Task Force at FBI Headquarters coordinates their work and makes sure intelligence flows among the local units. The task forces also train often, so that investigators and managers know each other before a crisis.

Violent crime follows a similar pattern of FBI cooperation. The FBI's Safe Streets and Gang Unit administers 182 Violent Gang Safe Streets Task Forces nationwide. The Bureau describes them as the vehicle through which federal, state and local agencies address violent gangs together. The concept expands cooperation and communication among those agencies and avoids duplicated investigative effort. These task forces pursue gangs through sustained, proactive, coordinated investigations aimed at racketeering, drug conspiracy and firearms violations. In 2005, at the direction of Congress, the FBI also established the National Gang Intelligence Center, which integrates gang intelligence from federal, state and local law enforcement and shares analysis with them.

Abroad, the partnership is more formal still. The FBI explains that its agents have no traditional law enforcement powers overseas, so they must rely on strong, mutually beneficial relationships with foreign counterparts. The Bureau runs dozens of law enforcement attaché offices, known as legats, and suboffices in key cities, providing coverage for more than 180 countries, territories and islands. More than 250 agents and support staff are stationed in them. Each legat is set up by mutual agreement with the host country and sits in the American embassy or consulate. The FBI conducts investigations abroad only when invited by the host country, and in most cases its international partners gather evidence and make arrests on behalf of, or in close cooperation with, the Bureau.

The legat is the Director's personal representative in the country. Typical duties include coordinating requests for assistance, sharing investigative leads, coordinating FBI training for local police and briefing embassy colleagues. Legats work with the Justice Department, the State Department and Interpol, and the Bureau supports Justice Department programs that provide long-term assistance to prosecution and police services in foreign countries.

The same cooperation reaches into the field with specific foreign task forces. The FBI's Transnational Anti-Gang task forces operate in El Salvador, Guatemala and Honduras. Each is staffed with FBI personnel and vetted officers from the Policía Nacional Civil of its country. They train officers in all three countries each year and exchange officers with FBI field offices to share intelligence and best practices. The aim is to investigate, disrupt and dismantle transnational gangs there and to supply intelligence for related investigations in the United States. The FBI says investigators there also work with partners on cases against the MS-13 and 18th Street gangs.

The overseas network has deep roots. In 1940 President Franklin D. Roosevelt assigned intelligence duties for different parts of the world to various agencies, and the Bureau received the Western Hemisphere. The FBI soon found it needed official liaison with the countries involved. In 1941 the U.S. ambassador to Colombia asked for a special agent at the embassy in Bogota, which became the forerunner of the legat program. By 1942 agents were assigned to the embassies in London, Ottawa and Mexico City. When the Special Intelligence Service was disbanded in 1947, the network of legats overseas continued its liaison mission.

FBI cooperation with foreign services has become routine. In virtually all major FBI investigations, a significant international connection develops, and some of the Bureau's most visible cases involve several countries. The FBI says it must therefore lean on the capability of the host country's own law enforcement, built through liaison, Interpol, its National Academy, working groups and training.

The Question

The Bureau is famously territorial — hoarding files, shutting out locals, playing lone wolf on every case. So how cooperative are they really with other agencies?

Show the answer

The Answer

The FBI describes a collaborative role. According to the FBI's own list of its top ten misconceptions, the idea that they don't cooperate does not match its account. Agents describe "close relationships and even friendships" with partners across the country and around the globe — so tight that things have gotten better since 9/11. They acknowledge occasional squabbles, while describing collaboration rather than isolation. The misconception is that the FBI works alone.

Send this question to a friend

Read next

By clicking “Send me a stumper” you agree to Crime Stumper’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.