Police uniforms and the preserved evidence of the 1929 massacre
Police uniforms were part of the deception at the Saint Valentine's Day Massacre, but the surviving evidence reaches beyond the disguise. On February 14, 1929, seven men were shot at the SMC Cartage Company garage at 2122 North Clark Street in Chicago. The Mob Museum preserves bullets, cartridge cases, coroner's material and bricks from the wall where the victims were lined up. Those objects connect the violence to particular people, locations and firearms. They also leave a significant boundary: identifying weapons is different from establishing who carried them into the building.
Two attackers wore police uniforms. The departure continued the impersonation: men in civilian clothes came out with raised hands, accompanied by armed men dressed as officers. The effect was an apparent arrest rather than a group of gunmen simply fleeing. Later reconstructions disagree about the total number of assailants, with counts of four, five or six. The disguise itself is supported by the museum's description of the killings and later historical summaries. It does not establish that the men were actually Chicago policemen.
The scene yielded different kinds of ammunition evidence. The museum's artifact catalogue identifies two Thompson submachine guns and a shotgun among the weapons used. Investigators collected cartridge cases and bullet fragments from the garage floor and placed them in evidence envelopes. Cook County's coroner brought Calvin Goddard into the investigation to examine the firearms evidence. The collection preserves the products of that inquiry rather than just a generalized image of a bullet-marked wall: fired material, documentation and comparisons undertaken after the shooting. The work began with recovered objects whose origins had to remain identifiable.
An envelope held a bullet removed from the lower right side of John May's back; another displayed bullet came from Adam Heyer's leg. The museum identifies May as a mechanic who worked for Moran's gang and was shot 10 times. Heyer was the gang's business manager. A photograph shows six victims' bodies on the garage floor after Frank Gusenberg was removed to a hospital, where he died a few hours later. Another photograph shows the coroner's jury examining guns, with Goddard seated beside Cook County coroner Herman Bundesen. These labels and photographs retain recovery histories within the larger collection.
The exhibit also includes a small box containing two bullets and two cartridge cases test-fired from a .38-caliber revolver. The museum's collection contains 23 such boxes. Test ammunition had a separate purpose from ammunition recovered at the garage: it supplied comparison material from known weapons. Goddard compared crime-scene bullets against bullets fired experimentally. The museum attributes the matching .45-caliber evidence to two Thompson guns later confiscated in rural Michigan. Its photograph of weapons and bulletproof vests associated with Fred Burke is credited to the Berrien County Sheriff's Department. The photograph and the test boxes document different stages of the inquiry.
Police uniforms also made the examination of police weapons consequential. The later historical summary records that Goddard tested Chicago police Thompsons and concluded that those guns had not been used in the killings. That was an exclusion of particular weapons, not a determination of every participant's identity. The Michigan comparison supplied a positive firearm connection where the police-gun tests supplied a negative one. Neither kind of result names the person who pulled a trigger. The distinction remains especially important in a case where suspicion attached both to gang rivals and, initially, to the apparent authority represented by the disguise.
Goddard's Chicago laboratory also helped train federal investigators. The FBI's institutional history records that its officials supported the Scientific Crime Detection Laboratory, then affiliated with Northwestern University. Hoover encouraged subscriptions to its American Journal of Police Science and sent representatives to Goddard's scientific-investigation symposium. Agent Charles Appel attended the laboratory's training program in April and May 1931, studying subjects including toxicology, serology and document examination. The Bureau subsequently supplied a fingerprint lecturer in return. This exchange placed the Chicago laboratory within a wider working network of investigators and examiners, rather than leaving its techniques confined to one notorious garage.
The wall followed a different route into preservation. When demolition threatened the garage in 1967, businessman George Patey recovered its bricks. The Mob Museum displays 300 of them and notes that earlier owners added paint to emphasize the bullet holes. That paint is a later alteration to the surviving material, not part of the shooting itself. The museum describes Capone's organization as widely suspected; its account of Jack McGurn says prosecutors filed charges and later withdrew the case. The preserved wall fixes the crime to a physical setting; the ammunition collections preserve specific forensic connections. The police uniforms explain the impersonation, while the exhibits retain the narrower findings the investigation could attach to objects.
- The Mob Museum, Machine Gun Jack McGurn leads list of Top 5 most notorious Mob hitmen, February 10, 2020: police disguise, staged arrest and withdrawn charges — themobmuseum.org
- The Mob Museum, St. Valentine's Day Massacre Evidence exhibit and artifact labels — themobmuseum.org
- The Mob Museum, St. Valentine's Day Massacre Evidence artifact catalogue — themobmuseum.org
- The Mob Museum, St. Valentine's Day Massacre Wall — themobmuseum.org
- Wikipedia, Saint Valentine's Day Massacre (later historical synthesis) — en.wikipedia.org
- FBI, The Birth of the FBI's Technical Laboratory, 1924–1935 — www.fbi.gov
- The Mob Museum, Artifact Spotlight: Frank Gusenberg’s Colt .38 Special Revolver: Herman Bundesen and comparison of police weapons — themobmuseum.org