Watergate break-in: the evidence behind the taped door
The Watergate break-in targeted the Democratic National Committee's headquarters, where surveillance equipment had already been installed on 28 May 1972. Five men were arrested there on 17 June while attempting to repair it. The return visit connected two kinds of evidence: equipment carried into a political party's offices and the security guard's written observations outside them. Later court proceedings would reach presidential recordings, but the burglary evidence concerned doors, tools and the identities of the men caught inside a Washington office building.
Frank Wills was working the midnight-to-7 a.m. security shift. The log reproduced by the University of Virginia's Miller Center records doors on basement levels B2 and B3 stuffed with paper. At 12:30 a.m., he switched off the hall lights and investigated. Finding a door taped open, he called police shortly before 2 a.m.
Connections emerged quickly. The Miller Center reproduces the FBI's 1974 review of its investigation, which says E. Howard Hunt's possible involvement came to the Washington Field Office's attention on 17 June. A country-club bill found at the Watergate Hotel and information in burglar Bernard Barker's address book pointed toward him. That evening, White House aide Alexander Butterfield told investigators Hunt had been a White House consultant. The next day, Butterfield identified Charles Colson as the official for whom Hunt had worked. On 20 June, Nixon and Colson discussed the Watergate break-in; Nixon said he expected it to be forgotten. The FBI review was written in 1974, while Wills's log records the night of the arrests.
The physical exhibits gave the Watergate break-in a more specific shape than the word burglary alone suggests. National Archives descriptions identify Government Exhibit 8 as a gym bag used to transport hand tools, light bulbs, listening devices and other equipment. Its contents included exhibits numbered 22 through 37. Government Exhibit 133 consists of two Bell & Howell H-10C microphones concealed in Chap Stick containers. The prosecution also entered panoramic views, elevations and floor plans of the Watergate and the Howard Johnson's Motor Lodge as Exhibit 1, locating the operation within its surrounding buildings.
The criminal proceedings encompassed seven defendants, although five men had been caught in the offices. The National Archives chronology dates the indictment of Barker, Virgilio Gonzalez, Hunt, G. Gordon Liddy, Eugenio Martinez, James McCord and Frank Sturgis to 15 September 1972. Their trial opened on 8 January 1973 before Chief Judge John Sirica in the federal district court for the District of Columbia. Hunt pleaded guilty on 11 January; Barker, Sturgis, Martinez and Gonzalez followed on 15 January. Liddy and McCord were convicted on all counts on 30 January. The Watergate break-in prosecution reached beyond the group arrested together.
Presidential conversations became another body of evidence. Alexander Butterfield disclosed the White House recording system to the Senate committee on 16 July 1973. A week later, the committee and Special Prosecutor Archibald Cox subpoenaed tapes and documents concerning the concealment of the burglary. The evidence also moved toward the House of Representatives. On 1 March 1974, a grand jury delivered a sealed report and recommendation to the federal district court; Chief Judge John Sirica subsequently provided it to the House Judiciary Committee. The document became known as the Watergate Road Map.
The Road Map's construction was unusually concrete: a two-page summary, 53 numbered factual statements and 97 supporting documents matched to those statements. Many of the numbered statements and 90 supporting documents had already been published in congressional hearings or located elsewhere in the public domain. The National Archives distinguishes this grand-jury document from related prosecutorial analyses held alongside it. Its 2018 release retained redactions for material that could not be confirmed as already public and remained protected grand-jury information.
The Supreme Court's decision in United States v. Nixon concerned production of evidence for a pending criminal prosecution. The special prosecutor sought recordings and documents tied to specifically identified presidential meetings. White House daily logs and appointment records had enabled him to identify their times, places and participants. Nixon moved to quash the subpoena and asserted executive privilege. On 24 July 1974, the Court upheld the order requiring production for private judicial examination. Its ruling recognized the importance of presidential confidentiality while holding that a generalized confidentiality claim must yield to a demonstrated, specific need for evidence in a criminal trial.
The Court also required protection for presidential material irrelevant to the prosecution, including its return under seal. Access to the recordings therefore came through a defined judicial process with safeguards for material outside the case. The National Archives chronology places the House Judiciary Committee's three impeachment resolutions later that July and Nixon's resignation on 9 August 1974. Gerald Ford pardoned Nixon on 8 September. The Supreme Court's production order, the committee's impeachment recommendations and the presidential pardon were distinct acts following the prosecution of the burglary itself.
- National Archives, U.S. v. Liddy Trial Records and Government Exhibits; exhibits 1, 8, 133 and 162H — www.archives.gov
- University of Virginia Miller Center, Watergate: The break-in; reproduced security log and FBI investigative review — millercenter.org
- National Archives, Watergate and the Constitution: A Chronology — www.archives.gov
- National Archives, Watergate Road Map; description of the grand jury report and its attachments — www.archives.gov
- Supreme Court of the United States, United States v. Nixon, 418 U.S. 683, 24 July 1974; text at Cornell LII — www.law.cornell.edu