Stella Nickell: the laboratory trail behind the Excedrin case
Stella Nickell was convicted after poisoned Excedrin capsules killed her husband Bruce Nickell and Sue Snow, a woman she did not know. Their deaths in Auburn, Washington, in June 1986 triggered laboratory screening, a federal investigation and a prosecution under the Federal Anti-Tampering Act. The evidence followed different paths: tests identified cyanide in medicine, investigators connected the contamination to Nickell, and a later appeal examined the conduct of the jury. An FDA scientist's recollection adds another part of the investigation: how staff examined the incoming bottles without opening every capsule by hand.
Bruce died on 5 June, and his death was initially attributed to emphysema. Snow died on 11 June after taking Extra Strength Excedrin. Cyanide was identified, and the manufacturer, Bristol-Myers, recalled the capsules nationwide. When investigators publicised the lot number from Snow's bottle, Stella Nickell contacted police and handed over two bottles that also contained poisoned capsules. Subsequent testing of Bruce's blood identified cyanide poisoning. The revised cause of death also changed the insurance position: an additional $100,000 was payable for accidental death. Detecting the poison therefore connected two deaths initially treated differently and supplied a financial line of inquiry.
Marleen Wekell, acting director of the FDA's Seattle laboratory during the crisis, described the screening work in an oral history recorded on 9 November 2011. Staff initially opened bottles and inspected capsules by hand. Before transferring Snow's bottle to the FBI, Wekell had it X-rayed on equipment belonging to the Coast Guard in the basement of the same building. She retained one image and sent another into the official records. The laboratory then rented two fluoroscopes to examine the large volume of collected medicine more efficiently. This was a response to the workload created by the recall, as well as to the individual death investigation.
Wekell showed the interviewers images in which contaminated and ordinary capsules appeared differently. She also described running positive controls during the fluoroscopic work to check that the screening continued to detect contaminated material. Daily records tracked how many samples had been examined and what staff found. Her recollection describes a laboratory operation extending beyond the collection of one incriminating bottle. The images, controls and sample records addressed the detection problem; they did not by themselves identify who had altered the medicine.
The legal framework already existed when Stella Nickell was investigated. Congress enacted the Federal Anti-Tampering Act on 13 October 1983, adding section 1365 to Title 18 of the United States Code. Its central provision covered tampering with consumer products affecting interstate or foreign commerce, including their labels and containers, with reckless disregard for danger and extreme indifference to the risk. Drugs were expressly included in its definition of consumer products. The law also authorised FDA investigations of violations involving products regulated under laws the agency administered. That express authority connected a consumer-product investigation with the agency's laboratory work.
The original statute separated attempted tampering, tampering that caused serious injury, and tampering that caused death. For a resulting death, it allowed imprisonment for any term of years or for life. Those provisions explain why the federal charges could encompass fatalities without being labelled state murder charges. The Ninth Circuit's subsequent opinion identifies five counts of putting cyanide into packages of nonprescription pain medicine. The FBI's Seattle history dates the guilty verdict to 9 May 1988 and records a 90-year prison sentence. It describes the prosecution for tampering resulting in death as the first of its kind in the United States.
The bureau's retrospective also states its conclusion about motive: Stella Nickell sought her husband's insurance money and placed additional contaminated bottles on store shelves to make the deaths appear to be the work of a serial killer. The regional history published by HistoryLink describes evidence developed along that path, including tiny green crystals identified as an aquarium algae treatment mixed with the cyanide. Investigators established that Nickell kept fish tanks and had purchased the treatment. Those circumstances connected a product found in her household activities with material inside the contaminated capsules; the laboratory's detection of cyanide had established a different part of the case.
The 1989 appeal concerned jury conduct and the judge's handling of deliberations. Juror Laurel Holliday received an anonymous telephone call claiming that Nickell had failed a polygraph examination, information the prosecution had not succeeded in introducing at trial. The government suggested removing Holliday, but the defence asked that she remain. She said she could disregard the call and decide on the trial evidence. The appellate court held that the defence had knowingly waived an objection based on that contact. It did not treat the caller's allegation as additional trial evidence against Nickell.
The court also considered instructions encouraging continued deliberation after a reported deadlock. The judge spoke before a weekend recess and reminded the jurors of their duties when they returned. Because there had been no intervening deliberation and no second deadlock, the Ninth Circuit treated the later remarks as a continuation of the first instruction. On 29 August 1989, it affirmed the conviction. The ruling addressed the fairness issues raised on appeal, while the FDA oral history preserves the separate work of finding contaminated medicine among the bottles arriving at the Seattle laboratory.
- U.S. Food and Drug Administration, oral history of Marleen M. Wekell, interviewed 9 November 2011, transcript pages 20–28 — www.fda.gov
- United States Congress, Federal Anti-Tampering Act, Public Law 98-127, 13 October 1983, 97 Stat. 831–833 — www.govinfo.gov
- U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, United States v. Nickell, 883 F.2d 824, 29 August 1989; text at Public.Resource.Org — law.resource.org
- Federal Bureau of Investigation, FBI Seattle History; 1986 investigation and 1988 conviction — www.fbi.gov
- Kathrine Beck, HistoryLink, Poisoned Painkiller Panic: The Snow-Nickell Cyanide Murders, 28 January 2004 — www.historylink.org