A Think Again Media Group publication
Crime Stumper

Which legendary crimefighter was never an FBI agent?

Eliot Ness: federal employment in the surviving files

By Phil Springer, Editor · Published · Crime Stumper

Eliot Ness: federal employment in the surviving files

On November 29, 1957, an FBI memorandum addressed a persistent confusion about Eliot Ness. A Scripps-Howard representative wanted to know whether the former Cleveland safety director had served in the Bureau's Cincinnati office. G. A. Nease told him no. The memorandum, preserved in the FBI's released Ness files, distinguished employment in Prohibition enforcement from appointment to the FBI. It also identified an August 1933 appointment in Cincinnati as a senior Prohibition investigator under Internal Revenue. The city was right; the agency was different.

Nease's explanation was more precise than simply calling Ness a federal agent. During part of the Prohibition unit's time under the attorney general, it had come under the Bureau's immediate supervision, he said, without being integrated into the institution later known as the FBI. Nease suggested checking Internal Revenue about the Cincinnati posting. That referral matters: even the official responding to the inquiry separated what the FBI's files recorded from what another employer could establish. Shared supervision did not turn every employee into an FBI special agent.

The FBI's later institutional history places Eliot Ness in the Treasury Department in August 1926, when he received his Prohibition appointment. He selected the small enforcement team associated with the Untouchables name. The agency says he never served as one of its agents, although he worked under J. Edgar Hoover from July 1 to August 10, 1933. It also records an unsuccessful application to join the Bureau that year, citing salary differences and his close relationship with the press. An application and a temporary superior are different pieces of personnel history from an appointment.

Federal alcohol enforcement already involved several institutions. The FBI's history assigns the main responsibility to Treasury and its Bureau of Internal Revenue, with the Coast Guard and Bureau of Investigation among the agencies playing smaller parts. Its description of the Untouchables emphasizes their reputation for integrity amid corruption surrounding bootlegging. Eliot Ness belonged to that particular enforcement effort.

The administrative overlap had a written basis. Franklin Roosevelt signed Executive Order 6166 on June 10, 1933, reorganizing numerous federal functions. Section 3 separated the Bureau of Prohibition's permit work from its investigative work. Permit functions were assigned to Treasury's Division of Internal Revenue. Investigative functions from Prohibition and the Bureau of Investigation were assigned to a Division of Investigation within Justice. Other Prohibition functions could be placed in Justice divisions at the attorney general's discretion. The order dealt with functions and organizational authority, rather than naming Ness to a new job.

The order made further distinctions between investigation, revenue collection and prosecution. Section 8 called for consolidating the Bureaus of Internal Revenue and Industrial Alcohol within Treasury's Division of Internal Revenue; Roosevelt subsequently postponed that provision's operation. Section 5 assigned federal prosecution and defense of government litigation to Justice, including decisions about whether to prosecute, compromise or abandon referred cases. It expressly preserved other agencies' functions before referral. Alcohol enforcement therefore crossed several administrative boundaries even within the same reorganization. The short period of Hoover supervision reported for Ness concerned that changing structure; it did not establish a separate appointment as one of Hoover's Bureau agents.

Eliot Ness next appears in the released files as a municipal official pursuing police reform. A May 12, 1936, memorandum to the FBI director collected Cleveland newspaper coverage, including a January 11 Plain Dealer description of his plans. The proposals included an immediate training school, stricter admission requirements for civil-service examinations, character investigations and fingerprinting of prospective officers. They also called for different requirements across police branches, assessment of temperament alongside mental and physical fitness, and removal of cadets who failed to demonstrate proficiency during a two-year probation. These were reported proposals, not a completed audit of their results.

The same memorandum preserved a dispute over assistance to County Prosecutor Frank Cullitan at the Harvard Club in Newburg Heights, outside Cleveland. Its newspaper excerpts said the prosecutor encountered resistance during a gambling raid and that Ness brought Cleveland police squads to help. The material also described the sheriff's insistence on a request from the local mayor. This episode placed Ness among separate city, county and municipal authorities. It also shows the texture of the file: contemporary reporting gathered by federal officials, rather than an FBI assignment directing Ness to conduct the raid.

Another surviving document keeps the Capone prosecution distinct from Ness's employment history. The National Archives at Chicago preserves the federal jury's guilty verdict in United States v. Alphonse Capone. The archive identifies the conviction as tax evasion in 1931, involving income from illegal operations, and locates the case among federal district-court criminal files in Record Group 21. A Prohibition squad's campaign against a bootlegging business and a jury's verdict on unpaid taxes concern different enforcement work. The verdict records the offense on which Capone was convicted; the Ness personnel memoranda identify where the celebrated lawman actually served.

The Question

Which leader of the Untouchables worked for the Prohibition Bureau rather than serving as an FBI agent?

Show the answer

The Answer

Ness. His career followed a different path. The Untouchables legend never wore an FBI badge: he worked for Chicago's Prohibition unit and later cleaned up Cleveland as its Public Safety Director. He did briefly work under J. Edgar Hoover and even applied to be a Bureau agent at one point. The distinction is between working under Hoover and serving as an FBI agent; Ness did the first. The Bureau itself lists this as one of the Top Ten Misconceptions in FBI History.

Send this question to a friend

Read next

By clicking “Send me a stumper” you agree to Crime Stumper’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.