A Think Again Media Group publication
Crime Stumper

Do mind-control beliefs really predict violence?

External control: why the violence findings differ

By Phil Springer, Editor · Published · Crime Stumper

External control: why the violence findings differ

A belief in external control can involve feeling that an outside force directs the mind. It belongs to a more specific research problem than whether someone has a psychiatric diagnosis. The National Institute of Mental Health describes psychosis as a collection of symptoms that can include delusions and hallucinations. It can occur in several illnesses and under other circumstances, including sleep deprivation or substance use. A diagnosis, a particular belief and a violent act are therefore separate observations. Research has to specify which experience was measured, when it occurred and what behavior followed.

Elizabeth Walsh, Alec Buchanan and Thomas Fahy's review of violence and schizophrenia describes the early interest in threat/control-override symptoms. The category combined experiences of being threatened with experiences of the mind being dominated by outside forces. Some studies found associations with violence, and later studies replicated those findings. The review also identifies weaknesses: retrospective designs, information collected for other purposes and limited measurement of both delusions and violence. A reported association involving external control consequently depended partly on how investigators classified experiences and reconstructed events. It was not simply a comparison between everyone with psychosis and everyone without it.

The same review contrasts those findings with the MacArthur Violence Risk Assessment Study. Its analysis found no increased violence risk associated with delusions generally or threat/control-override delusions specifically. Patients were followed after discharge, with repeated assessments over a year. Walsh and colleagues describe the original investigators' suggestion that self-reported experiences in earlier research may have included phenomena other than delusions. This disagreement concerns both findings and measurement. It leaves no consistent basis for treating a report of external control as an automatic forecast of violence, while allowing that symptoms may matter differently in particular circumstances.

Steven Honings and colleagues' 2016 prospective study offers a different population and a useful separation of outcomes. It began with 6,646 adults in the Netherlands and examined psychotic experiences below the threshold of a diagnosed psychotic disorder. The researchers considered physical violence, psychological violence and arrest separately. After adjustment for other psychopathology and contextual factors, hallucinations remained associated with physical violence, while delusions were associated with arrest. Delusions did not show the same association with physical violence in the complete sample. Because an arrest can involve offenses other than violence, those results cannot be merged into one general measure of dangerousness or attributed specifically to external control.

The Dutch study's limitations narrow the interpretation further. Physical violence was uncommon, leaving limited statistical power, and the timing of baseline lifetime experiences did not closely identify symptoms immediately before later incidents. The researchers could not establish the role of every individual delusional theme. Their findings describe broad categories, rather than a direct, isolated test of external control. The difference between a belief reported at some earlier point and a belief present during a confrontation is substantial. Both may enter research under a symptom label, yet they represent different relationships between experience and behavior.

Jeffrey Swanson and colleagues' 2008 CATIE research followed people being treated for schizophrenia. Its violence analysis covered the first 6 months of a randomized medication study, with 1,445 participants in the intention-to-treat group. Positive psychotic symptoms were associated with violence at baseline but did not significantly predict violence prospectively. The authors noted that treatment could reduce symptoms before later violence was measured. Prior violence, substance use, deprivation, victimization and childhood conduct problems also mattered. This was not a trial assigning people an external control belief. It shows why the same broad symptom category can behave differently when measured alongside treatment, personal history and subsequent events.

Ken O'Reilly and colleagues approached the relationship from another direction in a 2019 Irish forensic study. They examined 55 patients with schizophrenia or schizoaffective disorder who had already committed violent acts. Clinicians distinguished symptoms present at the time from symptoms judged relevant to the act. They also assessed moral ideas, such as perceived betrayal or obedience to authority. Symptoms generally were not associated with the seriousness or form of violence, while particular moral cognitions showed associations. The researchers explored whether those cognitions linked symptoms with violence. Their design therefore examined meaning and circumstances beyond the simple presence of external control or another delusional theme.

That selected group cannot supply the future violence rate among all people reporting similar beliefs. The Irish research was cross-sectional, relied on retrospective assessments and involved a small, predominantly male cohort. Its associations did not establish causal direction, and the authors called for further prospective work. They also emphasized that most people with psychotic disorders are not violent. NIMH describes recovery and the benefits of early treatment and support, rather than presenting psychosis as a fixed trajectory. Across these different populations and measurements, external control remains one possible clinical experience whose relationship with violence has yielded mixed findings. A symptom label alone leaves timing, emotion, treatment and personal history unresolved.

The Question

Do beliefs about outside forces controlling one's mind predict increased violence?

Show the answer

The Answer

The evidence is mixed. Some early studies suggested mind-control delusions could be linked to increased violence. Another strand of data from the MacArthur Violence Risk Assessment Study suggests those delusional thoughts are not associated with more violence. Most people with psychosis aren't violent, a useful fact to keep alongside the mixed findings. The data do not all point the same way.

Send this question to a friend

Read next

By clicking “Send me a stumper” you agree to Crime Stumper’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.