Cooper sedition trial: a printed reply becomes evidence
The Cooper sedition trial arose from a printed reply to a political insult. Thomas Cooper, a lawyer and newspaper editor in Pennsylvania, acknowledged that he had once sought a federal appointment from President John Adams. His critics presented that unsuccessful application as the explanation for his opposition. Cooper answered with a handbill criticizing the administration, and that publication became the basis of a federal prosecution in Philadelphia in April 1800.
The National Archives preserves the broadside alongside the warrant, indictment, plea, subpoenas, verdict, and sentencing papers. Historian John M. Lawlor Jr. identifies the newspaper attack that prompted Cooper's response as an item in the Reading Advertiser. The archive's collection connects the printed political dispute to the successive documents of a criminal case, rather than treating the handbill as merely an example of partisan journalism.
Cooper had emigrated from England in 1794. Bruce A. Ragsdale's Federal Judicial Center history describes his earlier support for the French Revolution and the suspicions with which Federalists regarded him. During a brief period editing a central Pennsylvania newspaper in 1799, Cooper joined criticism of the Adams administration. Adams told Secretary of State Timothy Pickering that Cooper's writings merited a sedition prosecution.
The handbill, headed To the Public, was printed at Northumberland in November 1799. It accepted one part of the attack on Cooper: he had applied for office. It challenged the conclusion drawn from it. Cooper argued that the application preceded policies he subsequently opposed. His published accusations concerned military expenditure, borrowing, the Alien Act, and presidential interference with a court proceeding. Those were Cooper's characterizations of public affairs, presented as reasons his earlier application did not invalidate his later opposition.
The Cooper sedition trial proceeded under the act approved on July 14, 1798. Section 2 addressed writings described as false, scandalous, and malicious against the federal government, Congress, or the president, with specified hostile intentions. The law therefore expressed requirements concerning both the writing and its purpose. Prosecutors maintained that Cooper's handbill satisfied them; Cooper contested that account of his publication and motives.
The statute also contained provisions that shaped the defense. Section 3 expressly admitted the truth of the publication as evidence and assigned the jury a role in determining law and fact under the court's direction. Cooper represented himself and tried to establish the accuracy of his criticism through public documents. His submitted plea denied guilt and listed twelve propositions he intended to substantiate, extending beyond the passages selected for the indictment.
Cooper also sought testimony from prominent officials. The surviving plea materials, reproduced in Ragsdale's study, requested subpoenas for Adams, Pickering, a State Department clerk, and members of Congress. Cooper believed presidential testimony would bear on the anonymous attack about his application for office. Justice Samuel Chase refused to permit the president's subpoena. The State Department stated that it did not possess the documents Cooper requested.
Chase presided with District Judge Richard Peters. William Rawle presented the prosecution, arguing that Cooper's extracts from public documents misrepresented the administration and demonstrated a purpose to defame Adams. Cooper, in contrast, maintained that examination of a president's public conduct was essential to electoral judgment. The two positions concerned the meaning and intended effect of the same handbill, as well as its factual assertions.
The Cooper sedition trial also exposed disagreement over the judge's conduct. Ragsdale describes Chase's defense of the statute in his charge and his presentation of arguments favoring conviction. The jury deliberated at a neighboring tavern for less than an hour before returning a guilty verdict. Cooper received six months' imprisonment and a fine. He continued political writing in jail and was released in October 1800.
The statute's own concluding section set its expiration for March 3, 1801, while preserving prosecutions for offenses committed during its operation. Cooper later sought repayment of his fine. A congressional compilation reprinted in 1838 preserves his petition and a succession of House Judiciary Committee reports from 1832, 1834, and 1836. The repeated reports document a prolonged effort to obtain legislative relief after the prison term had ended.
In that petition, Cooper argued that his publication concerned public official conduct rather than undisclosed personal misconduct. He also challenged Congress's constitutional authority to enact the statute and objected to the financial penalty remaining in the Treasury. The committee endorsed repayment, but the 1836 report noted that favorable reports had not yet produced a final House decision. Ragsdale records that Congress eventually authorized reimbursement to Cooper's heirs in 1850. The Cooper sedition trial consequently remained a matter of congressional business decades after the handbill first entered the court record.
- Bruce A. Ragsdale, The Sedition Act Trials (Federal Judicial Center), narrative and Cooper court documents — www.fjc.gov
- John M. Lawlor Jr., United States v. Thomas Cooper, National Archives case documents — www.archives.gov
- Congress, Sedition Act of July 14, 1798, 1 Stat. 596, GovInfo — www.govinfo.gov
- Congress, Sedition Act sections 3–4, 1 Stat. 597, GovInfo — www.govinfo.gov
- House Judiciary Committee, Thomas Cooper, Report No. 343, reprinted January 10, 1838, GovInfo — www.govinfo.gov