Haymarket pardons: three prisoners and a governor’s signature
The Haymarket pardons released three men from Illinois imprisonment in June 1893. Governor John P. Altgeld acted in the cases of Samuel Fielden, Oscar Neebe, and Michael Schwab, condemning the trial that had sent them to prison as a miscarriage of justice. The decision came after years of unsuccessful efforts to obtain relief and after the United States Supreme Court had declined the defendants' application for review in 1887.
The prosecution followed the Chicago Haymarket meeting of May 4, 1886. A bomb exploded during the confrontation between police and people attending the gathering. The National Park Service places the meeting within the labor campaign for an eight-hour working day and the controversy following police action against workers at the McCormick factory. Eight men were convicted in the subsequent criminal proceeding. Parsons was a printer and editor of The Alarm; Fielden was a Methodist preacher.
The defendants did not all meet the same fate. Albert Parsons, August Spies, Adolph Fischer, and George Engel were executed in November 1887. Louis Lingg died in custody. Fielden and Schwab had their death sentences changed to life imprisonment. Along with Neebe, they remained imprisoned until Altgeld's decision. The three releases in 1893 therefore concerned surviving prisoners, rather than a reopening of proceedings against all eight defendants.
The Haymarket pardons followed a failed attempt to secure federal judicial review. On November 2, 1887, Chief Justice Waite delivered the Supreme Court's opinion on the application for a writ of error. The defendants' lawyers challenged the Illinois jury-selection statute and asserted that the men had been denied an impartial jury. They also raised constitutional objections involving self-incrimination, due process, and equal protection.
Waite's opinion examined the federal issues presented by the state-court record. It discussed the examination of prospective jurors and the treatment of August Spies's testimony. The Court also considered an objection involving a letter attributed to Johann Most. It concluded that the federal grounds advanced did not warrant bringing the state judgment before it for reexamination. The discussion of the Most letter turned partly on the absence of a timely objection in the trial record, rather than a new determination of the letter's origins. The petition for a writ of error was dismissed, leaving that route to relief unsuccessful.
Brand Whitlock later supplied a personal account of the executive decision. In Forty Years of It, published in 1914, he recalled working in the Illinois secretary of state's office during Altgeld's administration. His account describes an accumulation of petitions, letters, and telegrams concerning the imprisoned men. Some appealed for mercy or reconsideration; others demanded punishment. Whitlock remembered the papers being gathered into a large box after earlier governors had taken no action upon them.
Whitlock's memoir is openly sympathetic to Altgeld. It describes the governor considering the case during the first months of his administration and recognizing that release would provoke powerful opposition. That portrayal belongs to Whitlock's recollection of the governor's purposes. It stands apart from the Supreme Court's 1887 account of the legal issues and from the recorded fact that the three prisoners ultimately received executive pardons.
In Whitlock's description of the morning of the Haymarket pardons, the governor's secretary called him in early and directed him to prepare the documents personally. Whitlock remembered taking the completed papers to Altgeld's office. A Chicago banker named Dreier, who had long worked for the men's release, was there. The governor signed the documents and handed them to the banker, who became too emotional to complete his thanks.
Dreier was to travel to Joliet and deliver the pardons to the men in person before accompanying them to Chicago. Whitlock recalled Altgeld interrupting the emotional moment to remind him that his train would leave. The banker rolled up the documents, picked up a small valise, shook hands, and departed.
Whitlock also remembered printed copies of Altgeld's explanation on the governor's table. He admired the decision but criticized the bitterness directed toward the trial judge in its explanation. His memoir subsequently described intense newspaper hostility to Altgeld over the pardons. These recollections document how an executive act became a political controversy, while the underlying trial verdicts and the Supreme Court's refusal of review remained separate entries in the case's history.
A different form of remembrance appeared at Forest Home Cemetery in Forest Park, Illinois. The Haymarket Martyrs' Monument was dedicated on June 25, 1893, by the Pioneer Aid and Support Association, which supported the accused men's families. Its granite shaft and bronze figures represented Justice placing a wreath on a fallen worker. The Haymarket pardons and the monument belonged to the same month, joining executive action with a public commemoration of the men prosecuted after the 1886 meeting.
- National Park Service, Haymarket Martyr’s Monument: trial outcomes, pardons, and dedication — www.nps.gov
- Supreme Court, The Anarchists’ Case, Ex parte Spies and others, 123 U.S. 131 (1887), Cornell Legal Information Institute — www.law.cornell.edu
- Brand Whitlock, Forty Years of It (1914), chapters XIII–XIV, Project Gutenberg — www.gutenberg.org
- Library of Congress, Haymarket Affair: primary newspaper collection and timeline — guides.loc.gov
- Haymarket Martyrs’ Monument: dedication history and National Historic Landmark references — en.wikipedia.org