Lufthansa cargo building: the warehouse, the shipping papers and the verdicts
The Lufthansa cargo building at John F. Kennedy International Airport housed the valuables taken in the December 11, 1978 robbery. In United States v. Werner, the Second Circuit described six masked gunmen entering around 3 a.m. and surprising eleven employees during a meal break. An employee was ordered to disable the alarm and open the storage room. The location was a working freight facility containing valuable shipments, with staff, cargo procedures and a secured room inside.
The 1980 opinion connected that room to an interrupted collection. On December 8, an armored truck arrived for $5 million bound for Chase Manhattan Bank. Lufthansa employee Louis Werner declined to release the shipment without a supervisor or security officer, a departure from usual practice. The truck left, and the currency remained over the weekend. The court affirmed Werner's convictions, including Hobbs Act offenses arising from the robbery. It recorded that prosecutors had identified him as the inside participant, rather than one of the gunmen who entered the Lufthansa cargo building.
The freight setting also had legal consequences. Federal law, 18 U.S.C. 659, addresses theft from interstate and foreign shipments, including goods held in warehouses and air terminals. It separately covers knowing possession of stolen shipment property. Its text treats goods as moving in commerce between their origin and final destination even when they stop temporarily awaiting transshipment. A shipment's movement therefore does not necessarily end merely because its boxes have been unloaded and placed in storage.
The statute gives shipping papers a specific evidentiary role: a waybill or other shipment document can establish the shipment's origin and destination as prima facie evidence of its interstate or foreign character. It also preserves a role for state law rather than occupying the entire field of such theft prosecutions. In Werner's case, the indictment included shipment-theft charges alongside the Hobbs Act allegations. The combination linked the theft to both the facility's commercial function and the particular property being handled there.
Decades later, federal prosecutors returned to the robbery through an organized-crime investigation. Their January 23, 2014 announcement described an indictment against five defendants for various offenses within a long-running racketeering conspiracy. Vincent Asaro was accused of participation in the Lufthansa robbery. The announcement attributed the investigation to the FBI and identified cooperating witnesses, consensual recordings, confidential sources, and electronic and visual surveillance among its methods. Those descriptions concerned the government's new case, separate from Werner's earlier prosecution.
The announcement alleged more than $5 million in currency and about $1 million in jewelry had been taken. It also alleged that Asaro, James Burke and their associates expected individual shares of approximately $750,000 plus gold jewelry. These were charging allegations, expressly accompanied by a presumption-of-innocence notice. An expected share was not a finding that any particular person received that amount. The distinction between planning a division and actually receiving property became material to the government's presentation of recorded conversations.
The accompanying detention memorandum set out the proposed evidence in greater detail. Prosecutors attributed their description of the gunmen detaining terminal workers and emptying the vault to cooperating witnesses. They also identified shipping documents and information from Lufthansa and Commerz Bank supporting the nature and value of the stolen currency and jewelry. The Lufthansa cargo building thus appeared in two kinds of material: descriptions of the encounter with employees and commercial documentation identifying what the airline had been holding.
The memorandum also quoted a recorded complaint that Burke had kept the proceeds. The cooperating witness interpreted that conversation as referring to the Lufthansa robbery. That interpretation belonged to the government's evidentiary presentation, rather than to a new conviction established by filing the memorandum. The document was a request for pretrial detention. Its descriptions of corroboration, anticipated testimony and recordings set out what prosecutors said they could establish, with shipping material addressing the property and witness material addressing participation.
The later procedural record prevents that accusation from being mistaken for a guilty verdict. A 2019 Supreme Court brief filed by the United States records Asaro's acquittal on the racketeering-conspiracy charge in November 2015. The Lufthansa robbery and Paul Katz's killing had been alleged as predicate acts within that conspiracy. The brief concerned a different conviction arising from an arson-related guilty plea and explained the sentencing court's later consideration of conduct presented during the earlier trial.
According to that brief, the sentencing judge considered the earlier evidence under a different standard, and the court of appeals affirmed the later sentence. That history does not turn the 2015 acquittal into a Lufthansa conviction. It distinguishes the verdict in one prosecution from findings made when imposing sentence in another. The warehouse location, the shipment documentation, Werner's earlier convictions and Asaro's later acquittal therefore occupy different places in the legal record, even though all connect to the same airport robbery.
- U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit, United States v. Werner, 620 F.2d 922 (1980) — law.resource.org
- U.S. Code, 18 U.S.C. 659, Interstate or foreign shipments by carrier; State prosecutions — www.law.cornell.edu
- U.S. Attorney, Eastern District of New York, Asaro indictment announcement, January 23, 2014 — www.justice.gov
- U.S. Attorney, Eastern District of New York, memorandum supporting pretrial detention in United States v. Asaro, 14-CR-26, pp. 23–26 — www.justice.gov
- U.S. Solicitor General, Asaro v. United States, No. 19-107, brief in opposition, November 2019, pp. 1–6 — www.justice.gov