Teapot Dome trials: leases, a loan, and separate verdicts
The Teapot Dome trials put a former secretary of the Interior, Albert B. Fall, at the center of a dispute over government oil reserves. Fall had administered public resources before receiving a criminal conviction for accepting money from oil magnate Edward L. Doheny. The proceedings involved more than one oilfield, more than one company, and several kinds of legal action. Cancellation of a lease, acquittal on a conspiracy charge, and conviction for bribery were separate outcomes.
The naval reserves were government lands set aside for petroleum needed by the Navy. The Supreme Court's 1927 decision in Mammoth Oil Co. v. United States described Teapot Dome as Naval Reserve No. 3, covering 9,321 acres in Wyoming's Natrona County. The reserve had been established by executive order in 1915. On May 31, 1921, a presidential order assigned administration of the reserves' oil and gas lands to the Interior Department, subject to presidential supervision. Fall and Navy Secretary Edwin Denby subsequently signed the disputed Wyoming lease for the government.
The lease went to Mammoth Oil Company in April 1922, with a supplemental agreement following in February 1923. The government's civil suit sought cancellation, possession of the land, and an accounting for oil removed. The district court initially dismissed the case after finding no fraud. The court of appeals reached the opposite conclusion, directing cancellation because of fraud and corruption. The Supreme Court affirmed the appellate decree in October 1927. That judgment dealt with the company's lease and obligations in a civil proceeding.
A different company and a different reserve figured in Pan-American Petroleum & Transport Co. v. United States. The Supreme Court's opinion described Doheny's November 1921 payment of $100,000 to Fall. Doheny's son obtained the currency in New York, carried it to Washington, and delivered it. Fall supplied a demand note. The Court recorded that neither principal nor interest had been paid and that the advance had not been entered in Doheny's or the companies' accounts.
The companies defended the transaction as a loan that had not influenced the government's decisions. They also contested the admission of Doheny's Senate testimony in the civil case. The Court found that he had acted for the companies when negotiating the contracts and remained authorized to represent them when he testified. His statements to the committee were therefore admissible against them. The Court sustained findings that Fall and Doheny had acted collusively and that Fall dominated negotiations. The resulting civil judgment canceled the California contracts and leases.
Congressional scrutiny extended beyond the Senate hearings associated with the Teapot Dome trials. A photograph preserved by the House of Representatives records witnesses at a House Naval Affairs Committee inquiry around 1924. Those pictured included Rear Admirals Luther Gregory and Julian Latimer, Representatives William Oliver and Fred Britten, and Admiral John Robison. The committee's inquiry concerned the leasing of naval oil reserves and the Interior secretary's private profit from government property.
Harry Sinclair's refusal to answer a Senate committee supplied another criminal case. In Sinclair v. United States, decided April 8, 1929, the Supreme Court reviewed his conviction for refusing a pertinent inquiry after being summoned as a congressional witness. The sentence was three months in jail and a $500 fine. Sinclair argued, among other things, that the inquiry concerned private affairs and that litigation over the leases had displaced the Senate's authority to investigate.
The Court rejected those arguments in the circumstances of the investigation. The title to government land and the means by which the lease had been obtained were public matters, and the inquiry could inform legislation about recovery of the reserves or administration of other public lands. The existence of court proceedings had not ended that legislative purpose. The Court affirmed Sinclair's conviction. The indictment had contained ten counts. Four were removed on a preliminary challenge and two were abandoned; Sinclair was convicted on four. The Court found the first count sufficient to sustain the sentence. This was a conviction arising from his conduct before Congress, rather than a bribery verdict against him.
Fall's own bribery jury returned a guilty verdict on October 25, 1929. The Federal Judicial Center's history records a sentence of one year in prison and a $100,000 fine. An appellate court affirmed his conviction in 1931, and he entered the New Mexico State Penitentiary that July. Doheny, tried separately for giving the payment Fall had been convicted of accepting, was acquitted on March 22, 1930. His trial lasted ten days from jury selection to verdict, and the jury deliberated for just over an hour. Fall and Doheny had also been acquitted of conspiracy in 1926. The Teapot Dome trials left a civil recovery of public property alongside criminal verdicts that differed by defendant, charge, and proceeding.
- Jake Kobrick, United States v. Albert B. Fall: The Teapot Dome Scandal, Federal Judicial Center (2020) — www.fjc.gov
- U.S. Supreme Court, Mammoth Oil Co. v. United States, 275 U.S. 13 (1927) — www.law.cornell.edu
- U.S. Supreme Court, Pan-American Petroleum & Transport Co. v. United States, 273 U.S. 456 (1927) — www.law.cornell.edu
- U.S. House of Representatives, Important Witnesses Before the House Naval Affairs Committee Inquiring into the Tea Pot Dome Oil Leases — history.house.gov
- U.S. Supreme Court, Sinclair v. United States, 279 U.S. 263 (1929) — www.law.cornell.edu