A Think Again Media Group publication
Crime Stumper

The names missing from two counties' jury rolls

Scottsboro jury cases: the missing names and the reversals

By Phil Springer, Editor · Published · Crime Stumper

Scottsboro jury cases: the missing names and the reversals

The Scottsboro jury cases brought Alabama's exclusion of Black citizens from juries before the U.S. Supreme Court. In Norris v. Alabama, decided April 1, 1935, the Court reviewed the conviction of Clarence Norris and found that the jury-selection system had denied equal protection. The dispute involved both Jackson County, where the indictment originated, and Morgan County, where Norris had been retried. It followed an earlier Supreme Court reversal addressing a different defect in the prosecutions.

The cases began in March 1931, after a freight train was stopped at Paint Rock, Alabama. Nine Black youths were arrested following a fight with white passengers, and two white women accused them of rape. Eight defendants were convicted in the initial proceedings. The Alabama Supreme Court set aside one conviction and affirmed seven, including Norris's. The proceedings became known collectively as the Scottsboro case, although the defendants subsequently had separate trials, appeals, and outcomes.

The first major federal decision was Powell v. Alabama in 1932. Its account described trials conducted amid intense public hostility, with militia guarding the prisoners and courthouse. The defendants were from other states, away from families and friends, and closely confined while proceedings moved rapidly. The Supreme Court recorded that each of the three trials under review had been completed within a single day. It examined the preparation and availability of defense counsel against that background.

The trial judge had described appointing the entire local bar for the arraignment, anticipating that lawyers would continue assisting if no other counsel appeared. The Supreme Court found the attempted designation too indefinite or too close to trial to supply effective assistance. Its decision addressed the denial of counsel under the Fourteenth Amendment's Due Process Clause. Although the defense had also challenged racial exclusion from juries, the Court confined that decision to counsel. The judgments were reversed, leading to renewed state proceedings.

In the Scottsboro jury cases of 1935, testimony about the selection process became decisive. Jackson County witnesses, including court officials, recalled no Black juror serving within their experience. The defense identified qualified Black residents, including school trustees, property owners, and householders. The Supreme Court found the evidence sufficient to establish discriminatory exclusion. The nominal qualifications written in Alabama's statute had not settled how local officials actually administered jury selection.

Morgan County supplied comparable evidence. A circuit court clerk testified that approximately 2,500 people had been called for jury service during his term, with no Black person among them. Witnesses identified many qualified Black residents, while the sheriff could not identify a Black name on the jury roll. The Supreme Court rejected general assurances that officials had performed their duties as a sufficient response to the specific evidence. It reversed Norris's conviction and returned the case for further proceedings.

Haywood Patterson's companion appeal had reached a different procedural obstacle. After his first conviction was overturned, he was retried in Morgan County. A judge set that verdict aside as contrary to the weight of the evidence, but a third trial in November 1933 produced another conviction. The Alabama Supreme Court then struck his bill of exceptions, the record containing evidence on the jury challenges, because it considered the filing late. It affirmed the judgment without addressing the federal jury-discrimination issue.

Patterson and Norris had challenged the same indictment and the racial composition of their trial juries. The evidence presented on Patterson's motions had been incorporated by agreement into Norris's proceedings. In Patterson v. Alabama, also decided April 1, 1935, the Supreme Court considered the relationship between these Scottsboro jury cases. Its decision in Norris had altered the constitutional setting in which Patterson's procedural appeal had been considered. The Court vacated Patterson's judgment and returned the case so that Alabama's court could reconsider its powers and the appropriate disposition.

Public campaigns proceeded alongside the litigation. Jay Bellamy's history in the National Archives' Prologue records a May 1933 march in Washington involving about 4,000 people. A petition with 145,000 signatures sought presidential intervention. President Franklin Roosevelt declined to meet the marchers, and the petition went to a White House secretary. The correspondence and demonstrations concerned federal intervention in prosecutions that were still moving through Alabama's courts.

The Supreme Court decisions did not immediately free all nine defendants. Charges against four were dropped in 1937, while others spent years in prison. Norris eventually received a pardon from Alabama Governor George Wallace in 1976. He died in 1989, the last surviving member of the group. In 2013, Alabama's Board of Pardons and Paroles granted posthumous pardons to Haywood Patterson, Charlie Weems, and Andy Wright, whose convictions had not previously been overturned or pardoned.

The Question

Which group was systematically excluded from juries in the proceedings reviewed in Norris v. Alabama (1935)?

Show the answer

The Answer

Black citizens. The Supreme Court found longstanding racial exclusion from juries in Jackson and Morgan Counties and reversed Clarence Norris's conviction under the Fourteenth Amendment.

Send this question to a friend

Read next

By clicking “Send me a stumper” you agree to Crime Stumper’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.