A Think Again Media Group publication
Crime Stumper

A spy ring's trusted contact had another employer

Duquesne spy investigation: the man behind the meetings

By Phil Springer, Editor · Published · Crime Stumper

Duquesne spy investigation: the man behind the meetings

The Duquesne spy investigation depended on William Sebold, a man recruited by German intelligence who instead cooperated with the FBI. His contacts thought they were dealing with a representative of their own service. The bureau's record identifies him as a double agent and connects his cooperation to a network of 33 defendants whose cases reached guilty pleas or trial verdicts in 1941. The investigation developed before the United States formally entered World War II.

Sebold had left Germany in 1921 and worked in industrial and aircraft plants in the United States and South America. He became an American citizen in 1936. During a family visit to Germany in 1939, intelligence officers recruited him. The FBI's account attributes his apparent cooperation to concern for relatives still in Germany. He informed the American consulate in Cologne that he wanted to assist the FBI, then returned to New York in February 1940.

This contact arrived amid a substantial change in the bureau's responsibilities. Its institutional history dates a presidential request for information about American Nazi groups' foreign connections to 1934. In 1936, the president and secretary of state assigned it intelligence collection concerning potential national security threats from fascist and communist groups. The Army and Navy also detected increased German and Japanese intelligence activity in the late 1930s. The FBI subsequently took the lead in investigations of those activities.

The bureau's wartime history reports that approximately 50 spies were uncovered in the United States before American entry into the war, including the Duquesne group. Domestic intelligence work developed alongside contacts with Canadian and British agencies. Responsibility for overseas intelligence was divided geographically, and the FBI received the Western Hemisphere assignment. Those institutional arrangements placed the New York case within a larger expansion of intelligence work, while Sebold's cooperation supplied a particular connection to the German network operating there.

The New York field office had an uneven earlier experience with a major German espionage case in 1938. Its own history describes that investigation as compromised by other agencies' actions and its investigators' inexperience. It contrasts those difficulties with the subsequent use of Sebold against the Duquesne network. New York remained a center of counterintelligence work during the war, supporting the bureau's Special Intelligence Service in the Western Hemisphere and maintaining links with British intelligence through the British Security Coordination Office.

Across the Hudson, the Newark office had undergone several reorganizations before the Duquesne spy investigation. Its personnel and records had transferred to New York when the office closed in January 1925. New Jersey investigations moved to Trenton in 1935 and returned to a reopened Newark office in April 1937. As overseas tensions grew, the state's concentration of military facilities and businesses increased the importance of national security work. In May 1939, headquarters suggested assigning one Newark agent exclusively to espionage investigations.

The eventual case required substantially more personnel. Newark's official history describes its agents pursuing a subsidiary group of more than a dozen spies within the Duquesne network. Carl Reuper and Paul Fehse were important figures in that group. Fehse had worked as a cook on ships sailing between New York and Europe. Newark agents arrested him before a scheduled March 29, 1941, departure from Hoboken for Lisbon. The regional account places that arrest within the investigation that culminated in the wider roundup.

Special Agent James E. Amos contributed knowledge of New York to the inquiry and followed Duquesne. The FBI's artifact history records that Amos joined the Bureau of Investigation on August 24, 1921. His earlier work included service in the Interior Department and Customs Office, followed by presidential employment and private investigative work. His bureau career lasted 32 years and included espionage, organized crime, and financial crime investigations. In the Duquesne case, his local familiarity complemented the evidence obtained through Sebold's meetings.

Motion-picture evidence gave those encounters a surviving visual record. The bureau identifies an Eyemo 35-millimeter camera in its collection as similar to cameras used during the investigation, rather than claiming it was the particular camera that filmed every meeting. Agents recorded Sebold's encounters with German operatives in a Manhattan office. The artifact history connects those films with the successful proceedings and reports combined prison sentences exceeding 300 years, imposed on January 2, 1942.

Nineteen defendants pleaded guilty, while 14 went to trial in Brooklyn beginning September 3, 1941. The jury found those 14 guilty on December 13. Duquesne received an 18-year espionage sentence and a concurrent two-year sentence for a registration violation, with a $2,000 fine. The Duquesne spy investigation had combined the double agent's contacts, field investigations, and recorded encounters in a prosecution encompassing both espionage and registration offenses.

The Question

Which man worked as an FBI double agent inside the Duquesne network?

Show the answer

The Answer

William Sebold. German intelligence recruited him, but he cooperated with the FBI, which recorded meetings between him and members of the spy network.

Send this question to a friend

Read next

By clicking “Send me a stumper” you agree to Crime Stumper’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.