A Think Again Media Group publication
Crime Stumper

A harbor explosion and a claim that outlasted the war

Black Tom claims: the long dispute after the harbor explosion

By Phil Springer, Editor · Published · Crime Stumper

Black Tom claims: the long dispute after the harbor explosion

The Black Tom claims carried the consequences of a 1916 harbor explosion into an international tribunal and a prolonged diplomatic dispute. The Mixed Claims Commission, United States and Germany, heard the compensation demands after the war. Its eventual awards followed earlier decisions rejecting liability and repeated efforts to reopen the cases. The proceedings concerned financial responsibility for sabotage losses, with governments arguing over evidence, finality, and the tribunal's continuing authority.

Black Tom was a munitions depot in Jersey City, New Jersey. The National Park Service's historical account describes ammunition and explosives stored in warehouses, railroad cars, and barges belonging to the Lehigh Valley Railroad because cargo ships were scarce. Explosions in the early hours of July 30, 1916, spread damage across the harbor. The attack was intended to interrupt supplies to Britain and France during World War I. Nearby military families and immigrants held at Ellis Island experienced the blast's effects far from the depot itself.

The Park Service records that windows shattered on neighboring Bedloe's Island and debris damaged buildings there. Ellis Island's brick buildings survived, but windows broke and the Main Building's roof collapsed. Detainees, staff, and civilian families were ferried away from the affected islands. Those physical consequences preceded the legal effort to assign responsibility and obtain compensation, which continued long after the warehouses and railroad facilities had ceased to be the immediate concern.

The commission consisted of an American appointee, a German appointee, and an umpire selected by both governments. The umpire's assigned role was to decide disagreements between the national commissioners, including differences arising during their proceedings. That arrangement later became central to the dispute over Germany's withdrawal.

The commission was established by an agreement of August 10, 1922. A German Embassy memorandum of May 4, 1933, placed the Black Tom claims among approximately 20,400 American claims submitted against Germany. The sabotage proceedings also included a separate fire at Kingsland, New Jersey, in January 1917. According to that memorandum, the American agent filed more than 1,300 exhibits. The materials included documents, affidavits, investigative reports, and records from government departments, while investigations extended across the United States and Europe.

The embassy's memorandum emphasized the opportunities both governments had received to present evidence. It described extended hearings and successive unsuccessful applications for rehearing. The original commission decision favored Germany in 1930. A first rehearing request was rejected in 1931, and a further application ended in another adverse decision in December 1932. These were the German government's stated grounds for insisting that the controversy had already been resolved. Its memorandum treated the agreement's promise to accept decisions as final and binding as an obstacle to another reopening.

The German position became more explicit in a July 6, 1933, communication from Chargé Leitner. He reported his government's rejection of both the factual basis for liability and the proposed procedure for resuming the cases. The letter invoked an earlier commission decision involving the Philadelphia Girard National Bank as support for the proposition that collecting new evidence did not itself justify reopening. It also disputed the American agent's renewed application based on additional witness testimony. These were objections presented by Germany, rather than an independent settlement of the controversy.

Leitner asked the United States to secure withdrawal of the pending reopening applications. Germany instructed its agent not to take further steps concerning those applications or participate in related hearings before American courts. The communication also connected proposed compromises in other pending matters with dissolution of the commission. Germany remained prepared to implement those compromises, Leitner said, but would not abandon the requirement that the tribunal's work end at the same time.

Acting Secretary of State William Phillips replied on July 20, 1933. He stated that the United States also wanted the commission's work concluded promptly, while maintaining that the pending sabotage rehearing petition should receive a judicial disposition from the commission itself. He had instructed the American agent to seek completion around October, including awards in cases where tentative agreements existed. Phillips made that timetable dependent on German cooperation and on the continuing collection of testimony. He also distinguished late claims, for which a separate arrangement remained necessary.

The Black Tom claims ultimately reached a different result in 1939. As the Supreme Court later recounted in Z. & F. Assets Realization Corp. v. Hull, the German commissioner withdrew on March 1. The umpire nevertheless determined in June that withdrawal had not ended the commission's authority and that Germany's liability had been established. Awards followed on October 30 and were certified by the secretary of state the next day. Other award holders then challenged them, fearing depletion of the payment fund. On January 6, 1941, the Supreme Court affirmed dismissal of that challenge, treating the secretary's certification as conclusive for payment under the governing statute.

The Question

Which body heard the Black Tom damage claims against Germany?

Show the answer

The Answer

The Mixed Claims Commission, United States and Germany. The two governments established it in 1922, and the Black Tom claims underwent years of decisions and rehearing proceedings before awards were made in 1939.

Send this question to a friend

Read next

By clicking “Send me a stumper” you agree to Crime Stumper’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.