Irish Crown Jewels: the safe, the keys and the custody inquiry
The Irish Crown Jewels disappeared from Dublin Castle in 1907, leaving the cases that had held the Grand Master's diamond star and badge empty. The ornaments belonged to the Order of St Patrick, whose Grand Master was the Lord Lieutenant of Ireland. Their loss interrupted a specific ceremony: Lord Castletown was to enter the order during the approaching visit of Edward VII and Queen Alexandra. The investiture was cancelled. Behind that public embarrassment lay a more closely documented failure involving the Office of Arms, a safe outside its intended strongroom, and warnings about doors found open at night.
The objects themselves carried the order's identity. The star had eight points, alternating four larger with four smaller, surrounding a ruby cross and emerald trefoil against blue enamel. The badge repeated the cross and trefoil within a blue enamel circle, with diamonds and an emerald wreath around them. The description preserved with the theft notices names the motto Quis Separabit and values the star at about £14,000 and the badge at £16,000. These were identifiable ceremonial insignia with recorded designs and dimensions. The familiar title Irish Crown Jewels referred to the star and badge rather than a crown worn at a coronation.
The order's rules made custody an official duty. The 1905 statutes, reproduced in the 1908 commission report, assigned the Grand Master's jewelled insignia to the Ulster King of Arms. They also required the collars and badges in his custody to be kept in a steel safe in the strongroom at the Office of Arms. The same extracts refer back to William IV's ordinance of 7 March 1831 and require each Lord Lieutenant to hand the Grand Master's insignia to his successor. The jewels thus passed between holders of an office under prescribed arrangements, rather than belonging to the personal collection of the current viceroy.
Those arrangements had broken down after the Office of Arms moved in 1903. The safe would not pass through the new strongroom's doorway. According to evidence from Board of Works chairman Sir George Holmes, he offered to move it inside by opening part of a wall or temporarily removing window bars. Sir Arthur Vicars, Ulster King of Arms, declined because of the space it would occupy. The safe stayed in the library pending a replacement. The commission found that it remained there until the loss. A doorway problem had become a continuing departure from the security arrangement specified by the statutes.
The discovery came through ordinary ceremonial business. On 6 July 1907, a jeweller's messenger returned the collar of the deceased Lord de Ros, which was intended for a new knight. Later that day, Vicars gave his own keys to office messenger William Stivey and instructed him to put the collar in the safe. Stivey found the safe unlocked. Vicars opened it and found the Grand Master's ornaments and several knights' collars missing. In his statement to police, he described the badge's ribbon and clasp left in the case after being detached. The missing Irish Crown Jewels had not been swept away together with their containers.
Earlier warnings had concerned different doors. The National Archives of Ireland's exhibition records the cleaner finding the building's outer door unlocked on 3 July, then the strongroom door open on 6 July. Those discoveries reached Vicars through Stivey. The safe itself was last known to contain the jewels on 11 June, when Vicars showed them to visiting librarian John Crawford Hodgson. That left an interval between a documented viewing and discovery of the loss. Neither the open doors nor the calendar alone established the precise moment when the ornaments were removed.
The locksmith evidence narrowed the possible methods. Specialists dismantled the strongroom lock on 8 July and the safe lock on 9 July. The commission reported no scratches or signs of picking on their levers. The experts considered that the locks had been opened with their own keys or keys identical in make and finish. The commissioners distinguished a skilled copy made from an original key from one made from a wax impression, which the experts expected to leave marks. Vicars held both safe keys. The inquiry criticised his practice of carrying one and keeping the other at home, recommending secure storage when they were not needed.
The inquiry's powers and conclusions had limits. Vicars refused to participate, objecting to its terms and powers; the commissioners later offered to hear him and his witnesses publicly, but he declined. Their report, dated 25 January 1908, found that he had failed to exercise proper care as custodian. It also explicitly said their remit was not a criminal investigation to identify the thief. Francis Richard Shackleton, whom Vicars suspected, appeared before them. They found no evidence supporting the suggestion that he had stolen the jewels. The custody finding and the statement concerning Shackleton were separate conclusions, neither a criminal conviction for the theft.
The aftermath generated allegations that could be tested independently. In 1913, Vicars won £5,000 in libel damages after the London Mail admitted that its story about a mistress obtaining a copied key was baseless and that the woman did not exist. A memorandum dated 1 June 1927 recorded that W. T. Cosgrave understood the Castle jewels were for sale for £2,000 or £3,000 and would recommend their purchase for the state. The memorandum recorded his information and proposed response, without documenting a recovery. The Irish Crown Jewels have never been located.
- Viceregal Commission, Circumstances of the Loss of the Regalia of the Order of Saint Patrick, 25 January 1908; report and appendices, University of Southampton digitisation — archive.org
- National Archives of Ireland, The Theft of the Irish Crown Jewels, 2007; archived exhibition with the 1927 memorandum — web.archive.org
- Office of Public Works, Dublin Castle, Chapter 12: The Illustrious Order of the Knights of St. Patrick; archived official history — web.archive.org
- Wikipedia, Irish Crown Jewels; transcribed police descriptions and the 1913 libel proceedings — en.wikipedia.org