A Think Again Media Group publication
Crime Stumper

The Great Gold Robbery's sealed boxes

Gold shipment: copied keys and the weight of lead

By Phil Springer, Editor · Published · Crime Stumper

Gold shipment: copied keys and the weight of lead

The gold shipment stolen on 15 May 1855 was supposed to travel from London through Folkestone to Paris. Its protection involved more than a locked door: bullion boxes were sealed, placed in railway safes and weighed along the route. Edward Agar's substitution of lead shot addressed one of those safeguards. Copies of keys addressed another. The Great Gold Robbery depended on defeating several checks in combination, with railway employees helping the thieves obtain access. Leaving a heavy box behind could conceal an absence of gold without explaining how the safe had been opened in the first place.

George Hayter Chubb's 1875 Protection from Fire and Thieves discusses the gold shipment while making a lock manufacturer's argument about security. He explicitly identifies his narrative as condensed from the Times's reporting, including Agar's evidence. That distinction matters: Chubb was reproducing testimony and drawing a commercial lesson, rather than describing a robbery he had witnessed. He explained that the boxes' weights recorded at Boulogne and Paris agreed with one another but differed from the figures taken in London. When the boxes were examined, lead shot had replaced bullion. The replacement concealed much of the missing mass, but the recorded weights still revealed a discrepancy.

Chubb's treatment places key custody at the center of the gold shipment's vulnerability. Agar sent a small consignment of bullion under an assumed name, then watched the collection procedure at Folkestone. The transaction showed where a key was kept. On another visit, Pierce obtained access while staff were occupied with an arrival, and Agar took a wax impression before the key was returned. Copies then required further work and trial journeys.

The later reconstruction assembled in the robbery's modern reference history describes Agar carrying scales and working on the bullion boxes inside the guard's van. He weighed removed gold and put lead shot in its place before repairing the bands and seals. The gold shipment included different contents in different boxes, including bars and American coins, so the substitution required attention to each container. On the last box the available lead was insufficient, and some gold remained. This detail limits the image of a perfectly balanced exchange: matching the whole consignment's weight exactly was an objective the thieves did not fully achieve.

Arthur Griffiths's Chronicles of Newgate, published in 1884, places the railway movements and the conspiracy's later collapse together. His narrative describes bags for carrying the shot and concealing the gold, the assistance of guard James Burgess and clerk William Tester, and Tester's removal of a portion at Redhill. Agar and Pierce continued beyond Folkestone to Dover before returning to London. The gold shipment's itinerary gave the conspirators separate jobs and opportunities to leave or rejoin the train. Chubb recorded sentences of 14 years' transportation for Burgess and Tester, and 2 years' imprisonment for Pierce.

Griffiths also linked the discovery of the conspiracy to a failure of trust after the theft. Agar was imprisoned over another offense. Money intended to support Fanny Kay and her child did not reach them as arranged, and Kay went to the authorities. Agar subsequently gave evidence against his associates. This route to detection differed from opening a suspicious box or spotting a false key: a dispute within the group helped expose the people behind the gold shipment theft. The physical safeguards and the human relationships each left their own vulnerabilities. Cooperation that enabled access to the bullion did not ensure loyalty afterward.

The expanded Rudimentary Treatise on the Construction of Locks reproduces J. Beverley Fenby's engineering discussion of an improved lock. Fenby said the gold shipment thieves had made 7 successive trials, improving false keys without alerting the owner. His proposed response was mechanical: a detachable key bit entered a rotating chamber, and an unsuccessful bit could be retained inside the lock. A thief would therefore lose the piece needed for further filing, while the owner would have a physical sign of attempted interference. Fenby's description connects a specific design choice to a specific weakness.

The accompanying engineering discussion also raised the possibility of trapping a legitimate key bit accidentally. Fenby described duplicate bits and a means of recovering retained pieces from inside the safe. Those exchanges record how the inventor defended his arrangement; they do not establish that every practical defect had been eliminated. Nor would a key-retaining mechanism by itself authenticate the contents or weight of a sealed bullion box. The gold shipment had exposed several separate dependencies: controlled keys, trustworthy staff, intact packaging and meaningful comparison of measurements. Lead shot helped disguise missing bullion, while the copied keys and insider access made the substitution possible.

The Question

What did Edward Agar substitute for the stolen gold to limit changes in the boxes' weight?

Show the answer

The Answer

Lead shot. Edward Agar weighed the stolen gold and substituted the material to limit changes in the boxes' weight.

Send this question to a friend

Read next

By clicking “Send me a stumper” you agree to Crime Stumper’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.