A Think Again Media Group publication
Crime Stumper

The forensic clue in Sherri Rasmussen's murder

Rasmussen murder investigation: the frozen swab and the change of suspects

By Phil Springer, Editor · Published · Crime Stumper

Rasmussen murder investigation: the frozen swab and the change of suspects

The Rasmussen murder investigation carried a physical clue from 1986 into a prosecution more than 2 decades later: material swabbed from an injury on Sherri Rasmussen’s arm. She had been beaten and shot in her Van Nuys home on February 24, 1986. Investigators initially pursued an interrupted burglary. The eventual identification of Stephanie Lazarus, an officer in the same police department investigating the death, depended on DNA recovered from the bite rather than recognition of a distinctive set of teeth.

A primary statement of the prosecution’s reasoning survives in the California Association of Criminalists’ 2016 seminar proceedings. Los Angeles County prosecutors Shannon Presby and Paul Nunez described a bite on the left inner forearm, blows to the head and face, and 3 shots to the chest. One gunshot was a contact wound, with the barrel against Rasmussen’s body. Their presentation grouped the physical evidence with a proposed motive: jealousy over her marriage to John Ruetten. It was a presentation by the advocates who tried the case, with an explicitly prosecutorial interpretation of the evidence.

Presby and Nunez linked that interpretation to events before the killing. Lazarus and Ruetten had known each other at UCLA and had an intimate relationship afterward. Ruetten became engaged to Rasmussen in 1985. The prosecutors described Lazarus’s distress in her journal, her attempt to persuade Ruetten to change his mind, and her confrontation with Rasmussen at work. Ruetten and Rasmussen married in November 1985. Those circumstances supplied a reason to investigate a particular woman; they were different evidence from the biological material that could connect a person to the injury.

The early burglary theory had physical features behind it. Stereo equipment had been pulled out and left stacked inside the condominium, and Rasmussen’s car was missing. But jewelry remained, and the front door showed no forced entry. Later investigators treated the arrangement of the equipment as potentially staged. The Rasmussen murder investigation therefore involved 2 linked problems: identifying whose biological material was present and reconsidering what the scene indicated about the purpose of the intrusion. The laboratory result did not make the original interpretation of the room automatically reliable.

The swab’s survival mattered before any suspect comparison could occur. The criminalist who noticed the injury collected material from its surface. In their 2016 presentation, the prosecutors emphasized that this material spent more than 18 years frozen at the coroner’s office. A visible wound had supplied something that could be preserved separately from the body. Later testing could examine the stored material even though the original scene was long gone. That possibility depended on the collection and retention of a physical sample, rather than on a photograph of the injury alone.

The National Institute of Justice describes the relevant laboratory distinction. DNA analysis separates genetic material from a biological sample, measures and copies selected regions, then compares the resulting profile with reference samples. Short tandem repeat analysis examines particular regions of nuclear DNA. It can exclude a person whose profile differs or include a person as a possible source. A reported random match probability concerns how often an unrelated person’s profile would match at the tested markers. It is a statement about the genetic comparison, rather than a reconstruction of every action during a crime.

Testing of the bite swab yielded a female profile distinct from Rasmussen’s. A search of the national DNA database did not identify its source. Investigators later considered women connected with Rasmussen’s life and narrowed their attention to Lazarus. In 2009, officers recovered a cup she had discarded after drinking from it. Material from that cup matched the profile associated with the bite. The Rasmussen murder investigation had moved from an unidentified profile to a comparison with a named suspect. That comparison involved recovered biological samples, distinct from remembered encounters between Lazarus, Ruetten and Rasmussen.

Recovering DNA from a bite injury differs from comparing tooth patterns. In its 2022 draft scientific foundation review, the National Institute of Standards and Technology found insufficient support for identifying or excluding a biter from marks on skin. Its review questioned the supposed uniqueness of relevant dental patterns, their consistent transfer to skin, and examiners’ ability to interpret the resulting marks. Skin can stretch and move; swelling and healing can alter an injury. Those findings concern the pattern left by teeth. DNA testing instead concerns biological material recovered at the location of the bite.

The defense challenged that material’s handling. Mark Overland pointed to storage conditions and a hole in the envelope containing the swab tube, arguing that contamination could explain the result. He also disputed the prosecution’s reconstruction of an apparently interrupted burglary and emphasized fingerprints that did not match Lazarus. These were challenges to the connection between the samples, the suspect and the crime scene. A DNA profile’s discriminatory power could not, by itself, settle whether the sample had been collected, stored and attributed correctly.

Lazarus was arrested in 2009 and convicted of first-degree murder in 2012. She received a sentence of 27 years to life. On appeal, she challenged the long delay before charges and argued that her police duties had made her pre-arrest interview statements legally compelled. The appellate panel upheld the conviction in 2015. It found no objectively reasonable basis for her belief that she was compelled to speak during that interview. The legal examination extended beyond the laboratory result to how investigators had obtained other evidence against her.

The Question

DNA from what injury helped solve Sherri Rasmussen's murder?

Show the answer

The Answer

A bite mark provided the DNA clue. A sample from Rasmussen's arm matched a covertly collected sample from Stephanie Lazarus, a Los Angeles police officer.

Send this question to a friend

Read next

By clicking “Send me a stumper” you agree to Crime Stumper’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.